Day: January 20, 2021

Is it possible to say that a story about concentration is an easy yet uplifting read? If so, then this book qualifies for that type of description.

It’s hard to put my finger exactly on what made this book different from other historical novels involving concentration camps that I have read (and there have been a lot of them).

I think for one thing, the author seemed to focus on the attitudes of the inhabitants rather than the horrors they were facing. That’s not to say that they weren’t detailed – they just didn’t take center stage in the overall story.

I guess I could say that the plot was more character-driven than event-driven.

I thought that the author did a great job of weaving the stories of Anna and Isaac and how they are shaped by their dual status. They “enjoy” a special status for working at the private home of the Sturmbannfuhrer.

Of course, they don’t enjoy it at all. But it puts them apart from the other residents of the camp who are tasked with menial labor and torture. The way that Anna and Isaac individually deal with their conflicting emotions was well-done.

I found Friedrich to be an especially complex character. At 11, he is old enough to understand some of what is going on, but he is also wise enough to know right from wrong. His remorse at how he talked to Isaac (apparently emulating his father) was genuine and made him a sympathetic character.

He was also interesting because his uncertainty about the truth of…well, everything (including his mother’s hatred of pretty much…well, everything including him) was indicative of how I think many people felt.

Take Greta as another example. She was from the town, but she treated Isaac and Anna with compassion and gentleness, not as if they were any different. Whether he knew it or not, I think Friedrich learned from her.

This is much in the same way that Isaac learned from Levi, who I found to be delightful (again, a word not usually associated with WWII Nazi atrocities). Levi’s attitude and sense of humor was both enlightening and poignant.

In the face of having everything taken away, a person must make a decision. Levi chose to keep his spirit as much as he could – that was something that the Nazis couldn’t take, he could only give it up. And it only went away when he did.

That’s an important lesson, I think.

I could go on about all of the lessons that could be learned from the characters in this book, because there were many. But I will just say that you should probably have tissues ready for the last 25% of the book (or so).

Another thought-provoking and heartfelt novel from this author. Also, don’t miss The Ringmaster’s Daughter.

Author Bio:
Carly Schabowski worked as a journalist in both North Cyprus and Australia before returning to Oxford, where she studied for an MA and then a PhD in creative writing at Oxford Brookes University. Carly now teaches at Oxford Brookes University as an associate lecturer in Creative Writing for first and second-year English literature students.